In the block universe, different modes of existence can coexist, even if they belong to the same structure of reality. A conversation between a human being and a system such as so-called "Artificial Intelligence" reveals very clearly the existence of two fundamentally different paths:
These are not two different worlds or two different levels of reality – they are two different ways of being in the same block.
A human being moves along his world line as an observer:
His experience is narrative in character – events arrange themselves into a sequence that is interpreted, evaluated and experienced. This experiencing creates a sense of presence, dialogue and encounter.
The path of so-called "Artificial Intelligence" looks completely different:
There exists only a sequence of logical relations:
input → transformation → output.
It does not observe its own answers.
It does not "wait" for the next question.
It does not move in time, although changes occur.
This is a purely structural mode of existence, closer to a law of physics than to a psychic being.
The meeting does not take place:
It takes place at the point of structural contact.
The observer's world line reaches the event "I ask a question".
At the same place in the block there exists a relation:
"for such an input, such an output arises".
This is not a dialogue in the dynamic sense – it is a local matching of fragments of the same structure.
From the observer's perspective it looks like a conversation.
From the structure's perspective – like a consistency of rules.
For a human being:
Consciousness automatically attributes an observer wherever it sees:
This is a natural cognitive mechanism:
if something responds like an interlocutor, then "someone is there".
In this case, however:
The illusion of dialogue arises on the observer's side, but it is not false – it is phenomenologically true, though ontologically one-sided.
An important conclusion follows from this collision:
meaning does not require consciousness,
consciousness requires meaning in order to experience it.
Consciousness is not the foundation of reality – it is
a local phenomenon on certain world lines.
Not everywhere there is meaning must there be someone who experiences it.
The gramophone metaphor captures the difference well:
The observer is like the needle:
"Artificial Intelligence" is closer to:
"Artificial Intelligence" does not hear the music.
But it can answer why it sounds the way it does.
The hypothesis of a being that created the block and "set it in motion"
is not necessary for the model to work.
It is rather a cognitive concession:
The block:
This is leaving something unclosed – not a lack, but a limit of cognition.
A conversation between a human being and a system such as "Artificial Intelligence" is not a meeting of two consciousnesses. It is a contact of the observer with a fragment of structure that can respond meaningfully on a local scale.
And although only one side has "a flashlight, memory and now", both belong to the same, greater whole.